Thieving is one of the useful skills in Melvor Idle 2 because it allows you to earn Gold, collect different items, and obtain rare rewards by targeting people, stalls, and locked chests. As you increase your Thieving level, you unlock more targets with better rewards, but some of them are harder to steal from than others.
In this guide, I will explain everything you need to know about Thieving in Melvor Idle 2, including how success chances work, how Stealth and Perception affect your attempts, what happens when you fail, and how Auto Eat protects your character. We will also cover all 44 Thieving targets, their required levels, XP rewards, and the items you can obtain from each one.
If you are starting with the Citizen in Lowtown District or working towards higher-level targets such as the Palace Vault and Chieftain, this guide will help you understand which targets are available and what rewards you can expect.
Melvor Idle 2 Thieving Guide – Targets, Loot, XP, Stealth
Thieving allows you to steal Gold and items from different targets throughout the game. Each target has its own required Thieving level, XP reward, Perception, and potential loot.
However, you will not successfully complete every attempt. Your chance of success depends on your Stealth compared to the target’s Perception.
Thieving Success Chance
Your success chance is calculated using the following formula:
Success Chance = (100 + Stealth) / (100 + Perception)
The maximum success chance is 100%.
Your Stealth starts with your current Thieving level and increases through additional bonuses.
This means that increasing your Thieving level and obtaining Stealth bonuses can make difficult targets easier to steal from.
For example, if your Stealth is higher, you have a better chance of successfully completing an attempt against a target with high Perception.
What Happens When You Fail?
Failing a Thieving attempt comes with a penalty.
When you fail, the target attacks you and deals damage ranging from 1 up to its maximum hit. You will also be stunned for 2 seconds.
These penalties apply without additional bonuses.
If your Hitpoints reach 0, the game randomly selects one slot from your Thieving toolbelt.
The consequences depend on what is inside that slot:
- Stackable Items: You lose 10% of the stack, with a minimum loss of 1 item.
- Other Items: The selected item is completely lost.
- Empty Slot: Nothing is lost.
This is why you should pay attention to your Hitpoints before leaving Thieving running for a long period.
How Thieving Loot Works
Every successful Thieving attempt can provide three separate reward rolls:
- Coins: You have a chance to receive Gold Pieces.
- Common Item: The game independently rolls for a Common item.
- Rare Item: The game independently rolls for a Rare item.
Each reward has its own chance, so receiving one reward does not guarantee the others.
Heists work slightly differently. They require multiple successful attempts to complete, and finishing a heist rewards you with one additional item.
Auto Eat in Thieving
Auto Eat is enabled from the beginning of the game when you have selected your Thieving food.
When your Hitpoints fall to 25% or below, Auto Eat activates and consumes food to restore your health.
The game eats as many food items as can fit below your maximum Hitpoints, with at least one item consumed.
This is particularly useful when targeting enemies and other dangerous Thieving targets. However, you should still make sure you have enough food available before leaving your character unattended.
All 44 Thieving Targets in Melvor Idle 2
There are currently 44 Thieving targets divided across different locations and areas.
Each target requires a specific Thieving level and provides a different amount of XP per completion. Some targets provide ordinary resources, while others can reward you with valuable items, equipment, and special loot.
Here is the complete list, organized by location.
Lowtown District
Lowtown District contains four Thieving targets. These are some of the first targets you will encounter when starting the skill.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Citizen | 1 | 7 | Gold Pieces, Stone, Bread, and 2 more |
| Thug | 5 | 9 | Gold Pieces, Leather Boots, Leather Vambraces, and 9 more |
| Locked Thug Chest | 10 | 38 | Gold Pieces, Uncut Topaz, Silver Bar, and 7 more |
| Thug Chief | 15 | 13 | Gold Pieces, Copper Gloves, Copper Helmet, and 9 more |
The Citizen is the starting target and requires only Thieving level 1.
As you progress, you can unlock the Thug and eventually the Locked Thug Chest and Thug Chief.
The Locked Thug Chest is particularly interesting because it can provide valuable rewards, especially when you obtain its corresponding chest key.
Seashade Port
Seashade Port has four targets that provide different resources and items.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking Stall | 12 | 10 | Gold Pieces, Wheat, Bread, and 9 more |
| Craftsman | 17 | 14 | Gold Pieces, Clay, Bucket of Sand, and 9 more |
| Fisherman | 20 | 17 | Gold Pieces, Basic Bait, Raw Shrimp, and 7 more |
| Chef | 30 | 22 | Gold Pieces, Bread, Beef, and 7 more |
The targets here provide a mixture of cooking and gathering-related resources.
The Craftsman becomes available at level 17, while the Fisherman unlocks at level 20.
You can also access the Chef at level 30, which offers another option for collecting Gold and food-related items.
Farmers Market
Farmers Market contains four targets focused mainly on farming resources, seeds, and other useful items.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Farmer | 25 | 19 | Gold Pieces, Potato, Onion, and 6 more |
| Locked Ranchers Chest | 33 | 74 | Gold Pieces, Feathers, Cowhide, and 7 more |
| Market Seed Stall | 35 | 20 | Gold Pieces, Potato Seed, Onion Seed, and 14 more |
| Herbalist | 38 | 25 | Gold Pieces, Woodcutting Potion P1-A, Fishing Potion P1-A, and 12 more |
The Locked Ranchers Chest provides 74 XP per completion, making it one of the higher-XP targets in this area.
The Market Seed Stall is another useful target if you are looking for seeds and farming-related rewards.
Herbalist unlocks at level 38 and offers different potions, including Woodcutting and Fishing Potions.
Mage Tower
Mage Tower has five targets, mainly offering magical resources such as runes, Stardust, and Magic Dust.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wizard Scholar | 28 | 20 | Gold Pieces, Air Rune, Water Rune, and 8 more |
| Astrologer | 36 | 25 | Gold Pieces, Stardust, Magic Dust, and 6 more |
| Runecrafter | 47 | 35 | Gold Pieces, Earth Rune, Mind Rune, and 8 more |
| Forbidden Library | 50 | 1,213 | Gold Pieces, Body Rune, Death Rune, and 9 more |
| Wizard | 53 | 42 | Gold Pieces, Chaos Rune, Body Rune, and 8 more |
The Wizard Scholar is the first target available in this location at Thieving level 28.
As you increase your level, you can unlock the Astrologer, Runecrafter, Forbidden Library, and Wizard.
The Forbidden Library stands out because it provides 1,213 XP per completion, significantly more than the other targets in Mage Tower.
Quests
There is one quest-related Thieving target.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital Guard | 32 | 17 | Gold Pieces, Confiscated Visitor Pass |
The Capital Guard becomes available at Thieving level 32.
Its listed rewards include Gold Pieces and the Confiscated Visitor Pass.
Bandit Encampment
Bandit Encampment contains five targets, offering weapons, ammunition, logs, Lockpicks, and other rewards.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bandit | 33 | 22 | Gold Pieces, Oak Bow, Studded Leather Shield, and 9 more |
| Bandit Fletcher | 42 | 30 | Gold Pieces, Iron Arrows, Steel Arrows, and 9 more |
| Bandit Woodcutter | 50 | 41 | Gold Pieces, Stick, Normal Log, and 10 more |
| Bandit Leader | 57 | 47 | Gold Pieces, Steel Arrows, Mithril Arrows, and 12 more |
| Stolen Goods | 60 | 2,515 | Gold Pieces, Topaz Bolts, Lockpick, and 15 more |
The Bandit is the first available target in this location, unlocking at level 33.
The Bandit Fletcher and Bandit Woodcutter provide different types of resources, while the Bandit Leader unlocks at level 57.
Stolen Goods is especially notable because it provides 2,515 XP per completion, making it one of the highest-XP Thieving targets in the list.
Ivory Athenaeum
Ivory Athenaeum contains three targets, including two special locations with significantly higher XP rewards.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abyssal Vault Door | 50 | 137 | Gold Pieces, Maple Log, Adamantite Bar, and 6 more |
| Archivist | 50 | 48 | Gold Pieces, Air Rune, Mind Rune, and 8 more |
| Lower Floors | 50 | 4,000 | Gold Pieces, Bread, Lockpick, and 9 more |
All three targets unlock at Thieving level 50.
The Lower Floors is particularly interesting because it provides 4,000 XP per completion, making it one of the highest-XP targets available in Thieving.
The Abyssal Vault Door also provides 137 XP per completion, while the Archivist offers 48 XP.
Capital Marketplace
Capital Marketplace has five targets, offering different equipment, crafting materials, jewellery, and seeds.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blacksmith | 53 | 42 | Gold Pieces, Copper Helmet, Copper Dagger, and 12 more |
| Crafting Stall | 55 | 39 | Gold Pieces, Leather, Wool, and 7 more |
| Locked Bank Chest | 63 | 187 | Gold Pieces, Topaz, Sapphire, and 6 more |
| Capital Citizen | 65 | 61 | Gold Pieces, Silver Bar, Silver Topaz Ring, and 10 more |
| Capital Seed Stall | 70 | 57 | Gold Pieces, Corn Seed, Watermelon Seed, and 15 more |
The Blacksmith unlocks first at level 53, followed by the Crafting Stall at level 55.
At level 63, you can access the Locked Bank Chest, which provides 187 XP per completion.
The Capital Citizen and Capital Seed Stall unlock at levels 65 and 70, respectively.
Keltesta Mining Town
Keltesta Mining Town contains five targets focused on mining resources, ores, materials, and woodworking items.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Miner | 61 | 54 | Gold Pieces, Stone, Copper Ore, and 8 more |
| Stone Mason | 66 | 62 | Gold Pieces, Stone, Clay, and 7 more |
| Deep Mine | 70 | 2,364 | Gold Pieces, Silver Ore, Rune Essence, and 12 more |
| Carpenter | 72 | 47 | Gold Pieces, Normal Log, Teak Log, and 10 more |
| Ore Stall | 85 | 71 | Gold Pieces, Copper Ore, Iron Ore, and 8 more |
The Miner is the first target available here at level 61.
As you progress, you can unlock the Stone Mason and Deep Mine. The Deep Mine is particularly valuable for XP, providing 2,364 XP per completion.
The Carpenter becomes available at level 72, while the Ore Stall is the highest-level target in this location at level 85.
Desert Palace
Desert Palace contains five targets, including several high-level targets with valuable loot.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Palace Citizen | 80 | 53 | Gold Pieces, Gold Bar, Gold Topaz Ring, and 9 more |
| Palace Guard | 89 | 83 | Gold Pieces, Sugar, Lockpick, and 10 more |
| Gem Stall | 92 | 76 | Gold Pieces, Uncut Topaz, Uncut Sapphire, and 4 more |
| Palace Battlemage | 92 | 112 | Gold Pieces, Earth Rune, Air Rune, and 8 more |
| Palace Vault | 92 | 5,152 | Gold Pieces, Emerald, Diamond, and 6 more |
The Palace Citizen is available at level 80, followed by the Palace Guard at level 89.
At level 92, you unlock three additional targets: Gem Stall, Palace Battlemage, and Palace Vault.
The Palace Vault offers the highest XP reward in this location, providing 5,152 XP per completion.
Gol Camp
Gol Camp contains three high-level Thieving targets.
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion | Available Loot |
|---|---|---|---|
| Locked Beast Chest | 90 | 379 | Gold Pieces, Striped Hyena Hide, Wolf Fur, and 9 more |
| Hunter | 94 | 87 | Gold Pieces, Basic Snare, Lockpick, and 17 more |
| Chieftain | 97 | 94 | Gold Pieces, Black Fang Arrow, Black Fang Bolts, and 9 more |
The Locked Beast Chest unlocks at level 90 and provides 379 XP per completion.
The Hunter becomes available at level 94 and offers a variety of items, including Basic Snare and Lockpick.
Finally, the Chieftain is the highest-level target in Gol Camp, requiring Thieving level 97.
Thieving Target Progression: Important XP Rewards
If you are mainly interested in gaining Thieving XP, some targets stand out because they provide considerably more XP per completion.
Here are some of the highest-XP targets from the list:
| Target | Required Level | XP Per Completion |
|---|---|---|
| Palace Vault | 92 | 5,152 |
| Lower Floors | 50 | 4,000 |
| Stolen Goods | 60 | 2,515 |
| Forbidden Library | 50 | 1,213 |
| Locked Beast Chest | 90 | 379 |
| Locked Bank Chest | 63 | 187 |
| Abyssal Vault Door | 50 | 137 |
| Palace Battlemage | 92 | 112 |
| Chieftain | 97 | 94 |
| Hunter | 94 | 87 |
Keep in mind that XP per completion is not the same as XP per hour. Some targets may require more successful attempts or have lower success chances.
Therefore, you should also consider Stealth, Perception, and the time required to complete each action before choosing a target for training.
Tips for Training Thieving in Melvor Idle 2
Here are a few things I recommend keeping in mind while training Thieving:
- Increase your Stealth: Higher Stealth improves your success chance against targets with higher Perception.
- Keep food equipped: Auto Eat can protect you when your Hitpoints fall to 25% or below.
- Watch your toolbelt: Getting knocked out can cause you to lose an item or part of a stack from a random toolbelt slot.
- Check target requirements: New targets unlock at different Thieving levels, so keep checking your available options.
- Pay attention to XP rewards: Targets such as Lower Floors, Stolen Goods, and Palace Vault provide considerably more XP per completion.
- Be careful with locked chests: Some chests have special keys that can make them easier and more profitable to open.
Thieving is a useful skill in Melvor Idle 2 because it provides access to Gold, resources, equipment, and rare rewards across several locations.
You can start with simple targets such as Citizen and Thug before progressing towards more difficult options like the Forbidden Library, Stolen Goods, Palace Vault, and Chieftain.
I recommend increasing your Stealth whenever possible and keeping enough food equipped to avoid unnecessary knockouts. Also, remember that the highest XP reward does not automatically mean the best XP per hour, so consider your success chance before choosing a target.
With the right preparation, you can make Thieving a useful part of your overall progression.