Gold is one of the most important resources in Melvor Idle 2. You need it to purchase upgrades, unlock new features, buy items, and make progress across different skills. However, not every activity earns the same amount of Gold, and choosing the right money-making method can make a huge difference, especially during the early game.
In this guide, I will show you the best ways to make Gold in Melvor Idle 2, starting from level 1 and progressing all the way to level 99. We will compare Fishing, Woodcutting, Mining, Smithing, and Thieving to see which activities offer the highest profits. I will also cover the Fishing progression ladder, the Thug Chest Key method, and the best money-making activity at different skill levels.
If you are wondering whether you should focus on Fishing, craft equipment through Smithing, or make money through Thieving, this guide will help you understand which method is worth your time.
Melvor Idle 2 Money Making Guide 2026 – How to Earn Gold
If you want a quick answer, Fishing is the best long-term money-making method because it can generate a large amount of Gold while requiring very little attention. However, Mining and Smithing are strong options during the early game, while Thieving becomes extremely profitable once you obtain the Thug Chest Key.
Here is a quick breakdown:
- Fishing: Best for long-term Gold generation.
- Mining and Smithing: Excellent for earning Gold during early progression.
- Thieving: A strong money-making option once you obtain the Thug Chest Key.
- Woodcutting: A decent alternative, especially at higher levels.
The important thing to remember is that you can only perform one action at a time. Therefore, choosing the right activity for your current level is important.
Which Skill Earns the Most Gold?
The following comparison shows how much Gold you can earn by sticking to a particular money-making path. Each path starts with a new character and uses the best-paying activity available within that path.
These calculations assume you sell everything you produce and do not have any additional bonuses.
| Money-Making Path | After 5 Hours | After 24 Hours | After 72 Hours | After 300 Hours | Level After 300 Hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fishing | 60,000 | 420,000 | 2,054,000 | 23,618,000 | Fishing 99 |
| Woodcutting | 61,000 | 391,000 | 1,522,000 | 10,671,000 | Woodcutting 92 |
| Mining and Smithing | 74,000 | 423,000 | 1,364,000 | 7,819,000 | Mining 83, Smithing 83 |
| Thieving | 69,000 | 389,000 | 1,302,000 | 6,208,000 | Thieving 85 |
| Mining | 43,000 | 255,000 | 893,000 | 5,915,000 | Mining 92 |
As you can see, Mining and Smithing perform very well during the first few hours because crafted equipment can sell for considerably more than the raw materials used to make it.
However, you need to switch between mining, smelting, and smithing to complete the entire process.
Fishing becomes more competitive as you progress. At around 24 hours, it starts pulling ahead, and by 300 hours, it generates more than 23 million Gold.
This makes Fishing a particularly good choice if you want a method that you can leave running for longer periods.
How Bonuses Affect Gold Generation
Your money-making results can change significantly once you start unlocking permanent upgrades and bonuses.
Some of the most important bonuses come from:
- Shop tool upgrades.
- Mastery Guild ranks.
- Astrology nodes.
- Pets.
- Skilling outfits.
These upgrades can improve gathering speed, increase item production, or reduce the resources required to create items.
For example, Smithing can benefit from Preservation bonuses because you can save materials when smelting and smithing. Pickaxe head upgrades also improve how quickly you mine ore.
Fishing has fewer steps to improve, mainly benefiting from reduced waiting times, item doubling, and special item bonuses.
Best Money-Making Path With Different Bonus Levels
Here is how the most profitable path changes depending on how many permanent bonuses you have unlocked.
| Bonus Setup | Best Money-Making Progression |
|---|---|
| No bonuses | Thieving until hour 2, Mining and Smithing until hour 24, then Fishing |
| Half the bonuses | Thieving until hour 32, Mining and Smithing until hour 96, then Fishing |
| Every bonus | Thieving until hour 104, Woodcutting until hour 120, then Fishing |
The biggest takeaway here is that you should not always stick to one skill from the beginning.
If you have no bonuses, Thieving is useful early on, followed by Mining and Smithing. Once you reach the right progression point, Fishing becomes the better long-term option.
With more bonuses unlocked, the time you should spend on each activity changes.
Best Money-Making Activity at Level 99
If all your skills are at level 99, you have access to much better money-making activities.
The following table compares the highest-paying activity in each skill with no bonuses, half of the bonuses, and every bonus.
All figures are Gold per hour.
| Skill | No Bonuses | Half Bonuses | Every Bonus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crafting | Silver Diamond Amulet: 51,782 | Silver Diamond Amulet: 114,605 | Diamond: 372,006 |
| Cooking | Whale: 129,133 | Whale: 217,969 | Whale: 359,515 |
| Fishing | Deep Blue: 165,738 | Deep Blue: 229,635 | Deep Blue: 311,220 |
| Fletching | Hard Oak Bow: 52,797 | Redwood Bow: 105,091 | Diamond Bolts: 258,123 |
| Woodcutting | Redwood Tree: 50,254 | Redwood Tree: 109,210 | Redwood Tree: 192,349 |
| Smithing | Dragon Dagger: 33,026 | Dragon Platebody: 91,843 | Dragon Platebody: 178,943 |
| Thieving | Craftsman: 25,255 | Herbalist: 61,829 | Capital Seed Stall: 150,169 |
| Mining | Jadestone Vein: 33,896 | Jadestone Vein: 81,473 | Jadestone Vein: 147,087 |
| Runecrafting | Soul Rune: 5,112 | Soul Rune: 29,338 | Soul Rune: 74,176 |
| Firemaking | Redwood Log: 3,494 | Redwood Log: 4,136 | Redwood Log: 4,637 |
One interesting result is Crafting. With every bonus unlocked, cutting Diamonds becomes the highest-paying activity in the skill.
This is because the Major 1 node of the Hyden constellation in Astrology adds an extra gem to every cut.
Cooking also performs very well because you can cook Raw Whales obtained through Deep Blue Fishing.
Keep in mind that these figures do not include additional bonuses from potions, food, bonfires, or rare events. The best activity is also selected separately for each bonus setup, so these numbers represent an ideal earning ceiling.
Best Fishing Money-Making Progression
Fishing is one of the best skills for earning Gold in Melvor Idle 2, especially once you reach higher levels.
The main advantage is that you can gradually unlock better fishing spots as your Fishing level increases. Each new location offers better earning potential, allowing you to move from lower-paying activities to much more profitable ones.
Here is the complete Fishing progression, including the level required, estimated time to reach each location, Gold per hour, and how long you should stay there.
Fishing Level and Gold Per Hour Table
| Starting Level | Time Reached | Fishing Location | GP Per Hour | Stay For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fishing 1 | Start | Shallow Pools | 3,006 | 6 min |
| Fishing 6 | 6 min | Calm Shallows | 5,528 | 31 min |
| Fishing 18 | 37 min | Dock Waters | 7,612 | 20 min |
| Fishing 23 | 58 min | Pebble Bank | 13,150 | 2h 36m |
| Fishing 39 | 3h 34m | Rapid Runs | 14,046 | 3h 53m |
| Fishing 49 | 7h 27m | Shimmering Depths | 15,428 | 4h 17m |
| Fishing 55 | 12h | Sea Edge | 21,111 | 15h |
| Fishing 67 | 27h | Gusty Cliffside | 26,074 | 13h |
| Fishing 73 | 40h | Vibrant Shallows | 35,779 | 17h |
| Fishing 78 | 58h | Glowing Rift | 41,920 | 19h |
| Fishing 82 | 77h | Tuna Run | 54,085 | 44h |
| Fishing 88 | 121h | Shark Cove | 79,234 | 58h |
| Fishing 93 | 179h | Luminous Abyss | 102,276 | 31h |
| Fishing 95 | 210h | Bountiful Corals | 102,665 | 59h |
| Fishing 98 | 269h | Deep Blue | 165,738 | From here on |
As you can see, the biggest improvements happen when you unlock higher-level Fishing locations.
For example, Deep Blue at Fishing 98 generates approximately 165,738 GP per hour without additional bonuses. This is significantly higher than the earlier fishing locations.
One thing to remember is that these calculations exclude rare drops that occur less than once per hour. For example, the Torn Ancient Sailcloth from Gusty Cliffside is not included, so your actual earnings can sometimes be higher.
Thug Chest Key: A Powerful Thieving Money-Making Method
Thieving is another useful way to make Gold, but there is one special item that makes it particularly profitable: the Thug Chest Key.
A locked chest can normally be opened using Lockpicks or its own key. However, the Thug Chest Key provides an additional 500 Stealth when used on the Locked Thug Chest.
This is extremely useful because the extra Stealth allows you to open the chest without failing or taking damage, starting from Thieving level 10.
How Much Gold Can You Earn With the Thug Chest Key?
With the Thug Chest Key, you can earn approximately:
| Reward | Amount |
|---|---|
| Gold Per Hour | 66,000 GP |
| Thieving XP Per Hour | 17,100 XP |
Around half of your earnings come from coins and common loot. The remaining Gold comes from rare drops, with approximately four or five rare drops per hour.
This makes the Thug Chest Key a strong option if you want to earn Gold while also training Thieving.
How to Get the Thug Chest Key
The Thug Chest Key consists of two separate halves.
- First Half: A rare drop from the Thug Chief.
- Second Half: A drop from the Locked Thug Chest itself.
To obtain the second half, you need to keep opening the chest using Lockpicks until it drops.
Remember that every attempt consumes a Lockpick, regardless of whether you successfully open the chest.
Fortunately, Thugs can drop Lockpicks, and the main quest called The Path to Melvor also rewards you with 1,000 Lockpicks.
Important Warning When Using the Thug Chest Key
There is one thing you should be careful about when using this method.
If your character gets knocked out while Thieving, the game destroys an item from a random toolbelt slot. This means you could potentially lose your Thug Chest Key.
Make sure you understand how Auto Eat and Stealth work before leaving your character Thieving for long periods.
Best Money-Making Method at Every Level
Not sure which activity you should focus on at your current level? This table shows the best-paying method at different progression points.
These calculations assume no bonuses and include the time required to gather and process ingredients for crafted items.
| All Skills at Level | Best Money-Making Method | Required Levels | GP Per Hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Citizen (Thieving) | Thieving 1 | 6,805 |
| 5 | Thug (Thieving) | Thieving 5 | 9,616 |
| 15 | Iron 2H Sword (Smithing) | Smithing 15, Mining 10 | 12,372 |
| 20 | Silver Topaz Amulet (Crafting) | Crafting 18, Mining 18, Smithing 18 | 23,221 |
| 40 | Silver Sapphire Amulet (Crafting) | Crafting 32, Mining 32, Smithing 18 | 23,356 |
| 60 | Gold Ruby Ring (Crafting) | Crafting 58, Mining 47, Smithing 38 | 24,058 |
| 70 | Dawnsteel Dagger (Smithing) | Smithing 70, Mining 70 | 30,378 |
| 80 | Glowing Rift (Fishing) | Fishing 78 | 41,920 |
| 90 | Shark Cove (Fishing) | Fishing 88 | 79,234 |
| 99 | Deep Blue (Fishing) | Fishing 98 | 165,738 |
As shown above, Thieving is a good option during the early levels, while Smithing and Crafting become more profitable as you unlock better equipment recipes.
Once you reach Fishing 78, Glowing Rift becomes a strong money-making option. At Fishing 88, Shark Cove offers even better returns.
Eventually, Deep Blue becomes the best option in this progression table, generating 165,738 GP per hour without bonuses.
Important: Thieving only becomes available after reaching Cooking level 10. If you are starting with a completely new character, you should begin with Stone gear from Smithing, which earns approximately 4,000 GP per hour.
Gold That Counts Toward Unlocking New Features
Not every source of Gold counts toward progression unlocks in Melvor Idle 2.
For example, the Shop and Ranching have specific requirements based on Gold earned from selling items.
Here are the requirements:
| Unlock | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Shop | Earn 250 GP from selling items |
| Ranching | Earn 20,000 GP from selling items and cut 200 Normal Logs |
The important thing is that only Gold earned from selling items counts toward these requirements.
Gold collected through Thieving, combat, or quests does not increase these totals.
So, if you are trying to unlock Ranching, make sure you actually sell your collected loot instead of relying only on Gold obtained from other activities.
How to Calculate Your Own Gold Per Hour
The numbers in this guide provide a useful starting point, but your actual earnings will depend on your current skill levels and unlocked bonuses.
If you want to compare different activities using your own character’s progression, you can use the Melvor Idle 2 Training Calculator.
The calculator helps you check:
- XP earned per hour.
- Gold earned per hour.
- Time required to reach a target level.
- Best training methods for each skill.
- How different bonuses affect your results.
You can use it to compare different activities instead of following a fixed progression path.
More Melvor Idle 2 Guides
If you are looking for more information about Melvor Idle 2, here are some other useful guides and tools:
- Money Making Guide: Compare 371 money-making methods, find the best progression path, and check Gold per hour.
- Thieving Guide: Learn about Stealth, chest keys, heists, and how to avoid getting knocked out.
- How to Unlock Every Skill: Find the requirements for unlocking every skill and menu.
- Training Calculator: Calculate XP per hour, Gold per hour, and the time needed to reach your target level.
- Item Lookup: Find out what an item does, where to obtain it, and how it is used.
Making Gold in Melvor Idle 2 becomes much easier when you choose the right activity for your current progression.
If you are just starting, Thieving and Smithing are worth considering, while Mining and Crafting can provide good returns as you unlock better recipes. Once you reach higher Fishing levels, locations such as Shark Cove and Deep Blue become some of the best ways to generate Gold.
I recommend focusing on Fishing for long-term passive income, but don’t ignore other skills. Mining, Smithing, Crafting, and Thieving can all be useful depending on your level and available upgrades.
The best strategy is to keep improving your skills, unlock permanent bonuses, and switch to better-paying activities as they become available.